ButterGirl decided to leave her retail career at the sparkling offices of Swarovski, Austrian crystal company, for a simpler life of baking goodness that brings joy to her customer’s taste buds.
What’s in a name?
When I was a kid, I lived in a divided family. One division was that my parents were divorced. Another was that one ate butter on everything and the other used margarine. My mother used margarine and I grew up in my mother’s house for the most part. If there was butter in the fridge, it inevitably had a taste that mimicked the smell of the fridge.
One day I decided to make some popcorn and melt butter on it. The butter tasted funny so I decided to use margarine. Ohhhh what a disaster! The margarine had melted into oil and the popcorn had turned a wet greasy mess. From that day on, I vowed to only use butter in any food I cooked or baked.
And baked I did! I baked for every track meet, every soccer game, every party. I was building a reputation for my chocolate chip cookies!
Butter in my mother’s house had become a precious commodity. In order to avoid that “funny” taste, I carefully placed the wax paper wrapped sticks of joy in airtight baggies to protect them.
As a result of this careful attention to butter, my step dad assumed I ate a lot of it and started calling me the “Cholesterol Queen”. I didn’t actually eat that much of it (not that I remember) but the name stuck.
When I started brainstorming names for the bakery, one thing I knew was that butter had to be in the name. It is the most important ingredient! Eggs, flour, spices, sugar, vanilla can all be substituted for a something else but BUTTER is essential. And since I am the “Cholesterol Queen” then I could also be called the ButterGirl.
People liked the name, I became the ButterGirl and a bakery was born.


24 Comments
Hi Laurelyn,
I can’t wait to try those cookies!
Lots of respect, and all the best.
JP
Laurelyn your cookies are amazing! Congrats and good luck!
You go, girl! This is awesome! Love the picture on the front – so many varieties!
Oh, and I just saw the stacks of cookies on the Cookie’s page —-YUM!
Laurelyn,
I am very excited for you. I wish you all the very sugary best.
Tim
Had some of your cookies delivered to me by a business vendor and they were beautifully wrapped and absolutely delicious! Unfortunately I had to share them with the office, but enjoyed one of the chocolate peppermint and the sugar cookies ~ everyone raved and they lasted only minutes. CONGRATULATIONS!
Jas
Hey LL, I’m sorry I didn’t get to say goodbye but we’re gonna miss u @ Rock Center you were the best. However my most favorite thing on earth is a cookie(fun fact u didn’t know) so I wish u all the best,and God’s blessing with your new move and I will be contacting u for my greatest weakness !
was walking at work last week and past by a table with some of your cookies out, i tried a few and cant stop talking about them. they were delicious!!
Hi Laurelyn,
I wish you great success with your new labor of love. There could be no better way to spend your days. I am looking forward to tasting your cookies. Love to John.
Best wishes and love,
Arlene
Hi Laurelyn, We received a large gift box on Friday and we wanted to say that we did exactly what your instructions said…. Best if eaten with 72 hours….. I don’t think it took that long…. Now we keep looking for more…. Congratulations on your success!
L to the L!
!!!
I love your cookies! Your Oatmeal Heaven is truly out of this world! I can’t wait to eat more! So much for fitting in to my dresses this summer, I’d rather eat your cookies
John brings in cookies for every one of our SPA Pilot classes and I thank you immensely for all of the hard work you put into the baking and for the delicious cookies!
My fave were the coconut, chocolate chip, pecan, and oatmeal ones. I just finished the Almond Crescent and I must say that is on my top three.
Our SPA Pilot class LOVES the BUTTER GIRL!!!
You rock! Keep up the wonderful work.
Hello Laurelyn: AKA ButterGirl : )
Just wanted to tell you that I loved your cookies! We tried and bought some at the Medford Market yesterday. Rest assured we will be back. The Peppermint Chocolate cookies are to die for. I have the same dream to start my own home baking business some day soon! Congrats!!! I LOVE your business!
Wow. Just tried a chocolate peppermint cookie from the union square market. Wow.
Laurelyn (ButterGirl): I am your newest biggest fan. So nice to meet you at The Burren SlamFest on Saturday. Looking forward to sharing your goodies with my friends.
Laurelyn:
Excited to hear that you are expanding. Love to spread the word with my friends about your MOST DELICIOUS treats.
I hope you do come up with some gluten-free cookies I can feed to my friend w/ celiac disease: if YOU do it, I know they will be fabulous!
Laurelyn:
I shared your peanut butter brownies with my colleagues and they were in love.
hfr
Had your peanut butter brownies. OMG good!
hi laurelyn!
i love your story and your butter creations!!!
Love love love your treats – can’t wait to see you at the Waltham Farmers Market again. The peanut butter fudge brownie was to DIE for. The spice cookies were good too though I personally like a little more spice. (I’m a bit of a spice whore.)
We stopped by last Saturday in Waltham. You gave us a couple of samples and we bought all your Carmel pecan short breads and a few other varieties. My wife is afraid now I may leave her for you LOL! OMG! I am eating one now and went to your website because I NEED MORE!
I’m the customer who brought you the Diet Coke today!
Love the ginger spice cookies and the brownie! Both amazing. I’m sure I’ll be back for more.
I’m so glad I finally tried your products! I bought the PB brownie and the oatmeal coco alm. cookies at Dave’s! YUM! I’m so full from their big sandwiches and your delicious desserts! I too ONLY eat butter, so these products are perfect for me!!
Write a Comment